Diplomacy News Logo

Race and Diplomacy: Foreign Policy Experts Discuss the Implications of Racial Injustice  

Troy Dorch

School of Diplomacy alumnus Troy Dorch moderated a discussion on the affects of systemic racism on American foreign policy.

Nearly six weeks after the attack on Capitol Hill, Seton Hall University hosted a virtual panel of three young foreign policy experts, the event was organized and moderated by Troy Dorch, M.A., '19, a member of the University's Diversity, Equity, Inclusion and Justice Coalition, to discuss the implications of racial injustice in American foreign policy. The three panelists invited were Lia Miller, a foreign service officer who previously served as chief of the Public Affairs Office at the U.S. Embassy in Yervan, Armenia; Asha Castleberry-Hernandez, a recent appointee as senior advisor in the Bureau of Near Eastern Affairs at the U.S. State Department; and Jessica Lee, senior research fellow on East Asia at the Quincy Institute.

The event began with an introduction by Courtney Smith, Ph.D., acting dean of the School of Diplomacy, who highlighted the strength of American foreign policy as an example to the world. However, the attack on Capitol Hill gravely tested this strength. Hence, the panel discussion raised the question of how racial injustice can hinder American foreign policy and become a national security issue.

Dorch raised a question of how systemic racism in our national security and foreign policy has affected our perception of threat. Hernandez's view was that the number one threat in the United States is domestic extremism, to which Miller added, "We do not have credibility to talk about terrorism and counterterrorism (overseas)."

Dorch also raised an important question as to was how systemic racism affects our credibility to promote human rights in East Asia. Lee responded with the belief of the Quincy Institute: "The U.S. must adhere to a principle of restraint using for sparingly and only a last resort. Creative and energetic diplomacy has to be more of a centerpiece." According to Lee, there needs to be a balance in promoting human rights and reforms domestically before we can promote human rights abroad.

Dorch asked Lia Miller, given her experience working overseas, she was asked how she counteracts negatively constructed narratives from our adversaries. Miller expressed, "I just have to show up; I am not the traditional foreign service officer. I'm a female, a woman of color. So, that in and of itself has a lot of power. " Lee also emphasized on the need for a more diverse workforce in national security, without which bad decisions are made from lack of different perspectives.

Discussing the topic of combatting systemic racism, Dorch asked the panelists what are the different ways to get African American and Latinx American communities to engage in foreign policy. Hernandez pointed out the increase in economic literacy and involvement such as rappers' interest in investing in Ghana. Lee stressed the need for current foreign service officers to offer strategic advice and open doors to help others, especially younger generations. Furthering the topic of engagement in the foreign service, Hernandez provided several resources for current students to look into, such as the Thomas R. Pickering Graduate Fellowship Program, among many others.

Dorch's final question to the panel was to describe the benefits of having diversity in foreign policy and how diversity can protect America under a new administration that is open to it. Again, Lee reinforced the notion of multiculturalism in the field of diplomacy, where it is strongly needed. Hernandez added that it can help us develop more effective solutions in foreign policy and decision-making. Miller proposed that the U.S. should be a model of creating ideal and inclusive foreign policy since she believes this allows us to be threatening to other nations that do not value multiculturalism.

Toward the end of the virtual panel, there was a question-and-answer segment, where audience members asked how to recruit mid-level professionals while retaining a diverse set of individuals. The panelists unanimously agreed on the need for promotions, sponsorships, and opportunities for career advancements to retain a diverse workforce.

Closing the event, Dean Smith and Troy Dorch echoed the sentiments of the panel on issues such as the discrediting of the American example to the world. They amplified the panel's subsequent strategies to regain credibility. The event ended with some additional advice the panel gave to students, such as the need to partake in internship programs and be more involved in future alumni. 

Categories: Arts and Culture , Nation and World

For more information, please contact:

  • Elizabeth Halpin
  • (973) 275-2560